Caramel Blondies

Caramel Blondies

I have never been a big fan of rules.  Mom will certainly be happy to tell you about how I always wanted to skirt the rules to back up my statement if you need proof.  Laws I like.  I like that people are supposed to follow a relatively small set of very important laws that are designed to keep all of us safe.  Speed limits are there for a reason and my heart races when I see someone clearly pretending there is no such thing.  It’s equally important that there be laws to protect our property and belongings from intruders, along with those on the books protecting us from far more heinous crimes.

But rules aren’t the same as laws.  Most of the time, they’re nuisances, just there to cause trouble and make our lives more difficult.  Like the rule at my grade school allowing girls to wear only clear nail polish.  Did they think some pink enamel was going to corrupt out minds, make us learn less?  Because I tend to think that’s one of the least important problems with the education system in this country.  A rule in our neighborhood that all the driveways have to be dark colored.  I don’t think the quality of life or property values are going to decrease because someone decided to put in a nice, new, not to mention quite attractive cement driveway.  But maybe that’s just me.

Blondie Dough

Baked Blondie Layer

Pouring Caramel

Caramel Layer

Unbaked Blondies

Then there’s the crazy formatting for pretty much any written document.  In school, it was MLA.  A fantastic paper could receive a not so fantastic grade if a student made a few formatting mistakes.  Writing and sending query letters for my novels should have its own college degree program.  I fear I’ve done something wrong every time I send one out, focusing so much on what’s double spaced and what’s not, if I’ve put the right words in the subject line, when really all I want, and they should want, is to tell them why they should represent me.  Of course, following all their rules hasn’t seemed to matter yet.

I try to give you recipes that don’t require a lot of rules.  Want to mix by hand instead of using a stand mixer?  Go for it!  Want to bake in a different pan?  It’ll probably work.  Like using paper liners for muffins instead of greasing the tin?  By all means.  But this, this isn’t one of those recipes.  I’ve tested these caramel blondies more times than I would like to admit, but I finally got them to work.  The thing is they’re quite finicky.  However, they are more than worth it.

Caramel Blondies

This original recipe of mine is my new signature treat, one of the best things I’ve made, something I think about eating and making again all the time.  These are seriously amazing!  AMAZING!!!!  The blondies themselves are the best I’ve ever had.  That classic crunchy, almost glossy blondie top that cracks with each cut of the knife or tasty bite, the firm, but soft bottom, and then the ooey gooey center that makes your mouth water with the mere site of it.  Never greasy, they’re the perfect combination of underbaked goodness and crunchy texture.  But see, that’s not enough for me.  So I baked half of the brownie dough, then poured a bunch of hot caramel over it before topping it with the rest of the dough and baking it again.  Some of the caramel bubbles past the top layer, some sinks below the bottom crust, some stays in the middle.  It’s all perfection, each bite an adventure so tasty and decadent you won’t be able to wait to take another.  Even if you have passed on blondies in the past because they’ve all disappointed you, give these a try, because I promise they will not disappoint.  So follow all the rules, make them and sit back and enjoy your effort.  I know you’ll love them.

Caramel Blondies

4.9 from 9 reviews
Caramel Blondies
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 24
  • 2 sticks unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour
  • ½ teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 cups packed light brown sugar
  • 4 large eggs
  • 2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
  • About ½ recipe Caramel Sauce, hot
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line a 9 by 13 inch pan with parchment. Do not butter the pan, but make sure the parchment comes up the sides of the pan. In a medium bowl, combine flour and salt.
  2. In a large bowl, mix butter and sugars with a hand or stand mixer on medium high until light and fluffy, about 8 minutes. This must be done with a mixer as its ability to incorporate air is vital. Add the eggs 1 at a time, being sure to incorporate each before adding another. Add vanilla and mix to combine, scraping down the bowl as necessary. Add the flour mixture in 2 installments. Mix until just combined, finishing mixing by hand.
  3. Spread half of the batter into the prepared pan. This is kind of tough since the parchment is not buttered, but take your time and it will work. Bake for about 20 minutes, until a toothpick comes out with only a few moist crumbs.
  4. While that is baking make the caramel. It is best to use fresh caramel. If you want to use some that you already made, be sure to heat it up well, so it is quite liquidy.
  5. When the blondie base is finished baking, it may cool up to 10 minutes, no longer, and it does not have to cool at all. Pour enough caramel over the base so that it is covered in a thick layer. The blondie will likely have puffed around the edges, leaving them bare and the caramel in the middle; this is fine. Do not spread the caramel to the edges; it will get there on its own. Take small clumps of the remaining batter in your hand, flattening them out and forming them before placing them on top of the caramel. Do this until the entire top is covered with batter, trying to avoid bare spots and sealing the edges as best as possible. The less you play with it the better as the batter will start to melt.
  6. Bake for an additional approximately 30 minutes, until a toothpick comes out of both the entire blondie and the top half with only a few moist crumbs. The top should be hard and golden brown and the caramel bubbling. Allow to cool completely in pan before cutting into bars. May be stored at room temperature for up to 3 days or frozen wrapped in parchment and foil and placed in a zipper bag for up to 4 months. Best thawed in a 350 degree F oven for about 10 minutes.



Pamela's Heavenly Treats
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. OMG YES @ the nail polish! I went to Catholic school and in grade/middle school their restrictions were SILLY for makeup and jewelry. And somehow the popular girls always got away with it while poor little me had to wash my face every day because my teacher was CONVINCED I was wearing mascara (my eyelashes are just naturally long and black! agghhh!)….high school was fine though lol. This blondies are so cool, I’ve never heard of caramel blondies before, I like it! 🙂

    • It was Catholic school for me too! Finally in 7th grade my teachers made some sort of secret agreement that they wouldn’t bust me for wearing nude nail polish, though I can assure you I was not popular. I think they let it slide because school was really tough for me. Other girls would actually ask me if teachers had told me to take it off yet, and I would just be like ummmm no and walk away before they could ask more questions 🙂 How nice you have such great eyelashes! Not that I can say no one else has ever made caramel blondies, but I kind of came up with the idea to try to make something unique.

  2. Wow Laura! So many things to touch on… first, I’m so glad you found a winning recipe like this. Those recipes are always the most stressful but well worth it in the end. The caramel swirl in the middle looks delicious, and the fact that you baked the bottom, then poured it on and then added the rest of the raw batter is so interesting! I love that! And your pictures are great! I can see you are working hard… it’s showing!

    and I can imagine how chewy and dense these babies are with all that butter and 4 eggs! I love blondies like this! 🙂

    • Thank you so much, Sally! It totally made my day that you think my pictures are great 🙂 The blondies are definitely a chewy and dense, super decadent treat, but what’s amazing is that they top and bottom bake up so firm. It’s like baking magic!

  3. These were my absolute favorites!! I’m gonna have to try making these for sure!! Thank you so much Laura!! 🙂

    • Thank you, Kristy! These were one of my favorites too. I hope you do make them. Of course, let me know how they turn out!

  4. Damn, these look gooey and delicious. I almost made blondies this weekend, but I got lazy and did krispie treats instead. I should have gone for the blondie!

    • Thanks, Sydney! They are as gooey and delicious as they look. There’s always next weekend 🙂 But krispie treats sound great too; in fact I have a twist on some for my next post.

  5. Um, YES PLEASE! Caramel AND Brownie?! Count me in!

  6. Those Blondies were great! The caramel was a nice addition to the original blondie that I’ve tasted. Always a favorite here!

    Thanks Laura!

    • Thanks, Lendon 🙂 The blondies are great by themselves, but the addition of caramel really makes them sing.

  7. The Best!!

  8. I loved the Blondie, it was the best! As a child my Mom made chocolate brownies with a sugar mixture cooked to a soft ball. I never learned to make it, but, the texture of your caramel blondie is very close to what I remember, soft and gooey in the middle. Thank you so much.

    • Linda, I’m thrilled you enjoyed the blondies! That is so interesting about your Mom’s brownies; I’ve never heard of making them like that, but I will look into it. I love things with cooked sugar syrup in them. If I can find out about it, you may see a recipe like that in the future here on my blog!

  9. Oh my gosh…these blondies sound incredible! I love that they have homemade caramel baked right in! 🙂

  10. Once again a great piece of work. i don’t know where you find these recipes but you make each one a hit..

    • Thanks, Eric! I actually came up with this recipe myself. I am happy with how it turned out and think it’s a pretty unique spin on blondies. It means a lot to hear you think so too 🙂

  11. The perfect alternative for those of us who think brownies are too…… chocolaty. Thank you, again, for the homemade treat, unfortunately it never actually made it home. It never actually made it to 8:30.

    • That is a huge compliment that it was consumed so quickly. Nothing better than an irresistible treat! Glad you liked it 🙂

  12. These are great. The caramel is perfect with the blondies.

  13. Hi Laura,
    Thank you for this wonderful treat, we all enjoyed them. Stan ‘s favorite is caramel anything! What a great idea to bake them twice, it really made a difference in the texture. I’m going to try and freeze them for the rest of the family, so they too can enjoy them when they come for Christmas! (warm and gooey in wintertime):)
    Keep those great recipes coming! Thanks again, Carol

    • I’m so glad you liked them, Carol! They should definitely freeze well and should be just as good as fresh as long as you follow the thawing instructions. Did you make a batch? Or just hide the ones I sent you before they vanished?

  14. Jenni Fillingim says:

    I would love to have your recipe for caramel brownies. How can I get it?

    • I just send you an email, Jenni! The recipe is there now. So sorry for any inconvenience. I think you’ll really enjoy the recipe, though!


  1. […] given the choice I am almost always go for the brownie over the blondie. Then I saw this recipe on Pies and Plots. I can’t say that I’m a convert. Brownies are still going to be preferred but man these […]

  2. […] – Biscoff! – and everyone loves them.  My absolute favorite recipes are the Caramel Blondies and Peach Blackberry Layer Cake.  They are much more complicated and labor intensive with […]

  3. […] been living in a very brownie-less world.  Sure there are lots of blondie recipes here (like these and these), but they’re just not the […]

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: