Fluffernutter Popsicles

Fluffernutter Popsicles - plus an awesome giveaway!

This giveaway is closed – congratulations to Susan on winning!

Everyone thinks of ice cream in the summer, but really I don’t think anything is more quintessentially summer than a popsicle.

It’s so inviting, with its portability and ease. You don’t need spoons or cups. No need to struggle with scooping ice cream that’s too hard and then melty because it’s too soft. You just grab a popsicle and go. Go for a walk. Go watch TV. Go sit on the deck. Go enjoy summer and life.

Fluffernutter Popsicles

Popsicles last longer than ice cream too. I can demolish a scoop of vanilla in like five bite, but a popsicle makes you slow down and work for it. It’s the best job ever, really, calmly licking an icy cold treat.

The flavors are endless too. I’ve always been a huge fan of fruity popsicles and grew up on creamsicles, but I had never made my own. I was excited to have fun with one of my all-time favorite flavor combinations – peanut butter and marshmallow.

This is perhaps more like a pudding pop – a good thing, since it’s half ice cream half popsicle. The creamy peanut butter mixes with the gooey marshmallow and some Reese’s Pieces add a bit of crunch.

Fluffernutter Popsicles

To make these even easier, I made them in Dixie cups. No need to go out and buy molds, just fill up the cups, stick a plastic spoon in the center, and freeze them. When you’re ready to eat, peel away the cup and you have a perfect popsicle.

My friends at Peanut Butter and Co have offered to give two jars of Smooth Operator Peanut Butter to one lucky reader.

To enter, answer the question: What’s your favorite frozen treat?

To earn additional entries:
Follow me on Bloglovin’. Come back and let me know you’ve followed in an additional and entirely separate comment.
Follow @piesandplots on Twitter. Come back and let me know you’ve followed in an additional and entirely separate comment.
Like Pies and Plots on Facebook. Come back and let me know you’ve liked me in an additional and entirely separate comment.
Follow Pies and Plots on Pinterest. Come back and let me know you’ve followed in an additional and entirely separate comment.
Follow @piesandplots on Instagram. Come back and let me know you’ve followed in an additional and entirely separate comment.
Subscribe to Pies and Plots via email using the form at the top of the page on the right hand side. Come back and let me know you’ve followed in an additional and entirely separate comment.
IMPORTANT: This giveaway is open to residents of the US only.
The giveaway ends Friday August 21, 2015, at 11:59 pm EST.
The winner will be chosen via the Random Number Generator on random.org. The winner will be notified by email and will have 24 hours to respond. If the winner does not respond, a new winner will be chosen. Good luck!

Disclaimer: I was provided with product and the giveaway, but all opinions, as always, are mine.

Fluffernutter Popsicles

Fluffernutter Popsicles

Prep Time: 10 minutes

Total Time: 10 minutes

Yield: 8 servings


¾ cup Smooth Operator Peanut Butter

1 cup milk (I used almond, use what you love)

½ cup peanut butter chips

½ cup Reese’s Pieces

About 1 cup marshmallow fluff

8 disposable paper cups and plastic spoons for molds


In a medium bowl, whisk together the peanut butter and almond milk until fully emulsified. Stir in the peanut butter chips and Reese’s Pieces.

Place about a tablespoon of the peanut butter mixture in the bottom of each paper cup. Place a heaping tablespoon of marshmallow fluff on top of the peanut butter in each cup. Divide the remaining peanut butter mixture among the cups.

Place a spoon in the center of each cup. Place in freezer until firm, about 2 hours. When ready to eat, peel away the paper and enjoy.


Additional freezing time is necessary


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. Debbie Eccard says:

    I haven’t had this one yet but just from your description and the pictures, this may be my favorite!!

  2. Debbie Eccard says:

    I follow you on bloglovin’

  3. Debbie Eccard says:

    I follow you on Pinterest

  4. Debbie Eccard says:

    I follow you on Facebook

  5. Debbie Eccard says:

    I follow you on Instagram

  6. Favorite frozen treat is probably ice cream, but these look pretty good too! Absolutely love the pb/fluffernutter combo

  7. Lisa Varner says:

    My fave frozen treat is probably Ben and Jerry’s Peanut Butter cup ice cream. Love that peanut butter!

  8. What a great idea! I agree popsicles are so much fun to eat, and definitely last longer. This is terrific — thanks so much.

  9. My favorite frozen treat is ice cream. Chocolate and dk cherry with chocolate chunks. Never tried peanut butter ice cream though. So this one I’ll have to try next.

  10. Ahhh I love that you put reeses pieces in there too!

  11. We are huge ice cream eaters, so this is definitely something we are going to try! You are so right that popsicles last longer than ice cream. We have learned that the hard way – in terms of brain freezes AND calories 😉 Thanks for the recipe! http://www.ourfoodieappetite.com/traveling-to-dubai-20-things-we-wish-we-knew-part-1/

  12. Susan Christy says:

    I love frozen Snickers bars.

  13. Susan Christy says:

    Follow you on Bloglovin’.

  14. Susan Christy says:

    Follow on Twitter – susitravl.

  15. Susan Christy says:

    Follow on Pinterest – susitravl.

  16. Susan Christy says:

    Follow on Instagram – susitravl.

  17. Reeses Pieces have gluten in them. It is a bit confusing because m&m’s are gluten free and Reeses Peanut Butter Cups are gluten free as well but the Pieces are not.

    • I just double checked the Hershey’s website to be sure, and they say Reese’s Pieces are indeed gluten free.

  18. My favorite frozen treat is an ice cream sandwich!

  19. I follow on Bloglovin.

  20. I follow on Twitter ( @acools )

  21. I follow on FB (Amy Maddux Cooley )

  22. I follow on IG ( @amymaddux )

  23. I follow on Pinterest.

  24. I’m subscribed to your email newsletter.

  25. I love frozen grapes! So easy and guilt free!

  26. I follow on Twitter (@RontalJudith)

  27. I like on FB (Judith Rontal)

  28. I follow on Pinterest (jrontal)

  29. I follow on IG (jlrontal)

  30. I love ice cream sandwiches 🙂

  31. hilary h. says:

    My favorite frozen treat has to be strawberry ice cream.

  32. Ice Cream is my favorite frozen treat, especially Dove Dark Chocolate Ice Cream Bars.

  33. steven taylor says:

    Love some frozen cut up bananas with peanut butter dipped in chocolate

  34. steven taylor says:

    Just signed up for email updates and following on IG and twitter as stangtx and taylors76 🙂

  35. My favorite frozen treat is ice cream.

  36. I follow on Bloglovin’.

  37. I follow on Twitter.

  38. I follow on Pinterest.

  39. I follow on Instagram.

  40. I like your Facebook page.

  41. I subscribe to your emails.

  42. carole jacobs says:

    I follow you on Face book

  43. Leland Lee says:

    Follow on Facebook. Ice cream is my fav.

  44. Leland Lee says:

    Followed on Pinterest

  45. Leland Lee says:

    Followed on Twitter

  46. Leland Lee says:

    Followed in Instagram

  47. Ryan origon says:

    I love butter pecan icecream!!!

  48. Ryan origon says:

    I am following on Twitter Mommytoryandll

  49. Ryan origon says:

    I am following on blog lovin Ryan origon

  50. Ryan origon says:

    I liked on FB Ryan r origon

  51. Ryan origon says:

    I subscribed by email Origonryan@yahoo.com

  52. Ryan origon says:

    I am following on Pinterest Mommytoryandll

  53. Ryan origon says:

    Following on ig Mommytoryandll

  54. these popsicles look SO simple and soooo delicious! and I always love pb & co 🙂


  1. […] Don’t forget about my Catching Fireflies giveaway that ends today, as well as my Peanut Butter and Company giveaway! […]

Speak Your Mind